Christ Came Through Solomon and Bathsheba. How did David's Son Nathan Come in to It? Reconcile the Genealogies in Matthew 1 and Luke 3?
1) Direct answer
There is no contradiction. Matthew gives the royal, legal line to Joseph through David’s son Solomon. Luke gives the natural, blood line to Mary through David’s son Nathan. Joseph is named in Luke “as was supposed” because he was the husband, the legal head; but the descent there runs through Mary, whose father was Heli. So Jesus has the legal right to David’s throne through Joseph (Solomon’s line) and the blood of David through Mary (Nathan’s line), all without being Joseph’s physical son.
2) Scriptural explanation
- Matthew’s record: “The book of the generation of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham” (Matthew 1:1), traces from Abraham down to “Jacob begat Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom was born Jesus” (Matthew 1:16). Notice it never says Joseph begat Jesus. It’s the royal succession through Solomon (Matthew 1:6-7).
- Luke’s record: “Jesus… being (as was supposed) the son of Joseph, which was the son of Heli” (Luke 3:23), then traces back through Nathan, not Solomon (Luke 3:31). “As was supposed” marks that men thought Joseph was the father, but he was not.
- The virgin birth: “A virgin shall conceive” (Isaiah 7:14). “The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee… that holy thing… shall be called the Son of God” (Luke 1:35). So Jesus is not Joseph’s seed.
- Yet He must be David’s seed: “Made of the seed of David according to the flesh” (Romans 1:3). Mary is of David (Luke 1:27), and the Lord gives Him “the throne of His father David” (Luke 1:32).
- The Jeconiah barrier: God said of Coniah/Jeconiah, “no man of his seed shall prosper, sitting upon the throne of David” (Jeremiah 22:30). Matthew’s legal line runs through Jeconiah (Matthew 1:11-12). If Jesus were Joseph’s physical son, He would be under that judgment. But He wasn’t Joseph’s seed; He was born of a virgin. Thus:
- Legal right comes by Joseph’s line through Solomon (Matthew).
- Blood descent comes by Mary’s line through Nathan (Luke), bypassing Jeconiah.
3) Simple clarifying logic
- Two sons of David cannot both be Joseph’s fathers. So one record is Joseph’s legal line (Matthew), and the other is Mary’s natural line (Luke), with Joseph named as “son” of Heli by marriage (a son-in-law). That fits the wording “as was supposed.”
- Matthew is about the throne—kingship—so it follows Solomon. Luke is about true humanity all the way to Adam, so it follows Mary’s bloodline through Nathan.
- God guarded the promise perfectly: Jesus is truly David’s Son by Mary, yet not under Jeconiah’s curse; and He holds the legal title through Joseph.
4) Reinforcing statement
You see, the Bible fits like a glove. The virgin birth, Davidic promises, and the two branches—Solomon and Nathan—come together in Christ without a single break in the Scripture.
Ask a Follow-up Question
What did the Laodicean Church Age (our age) Angel (- messenger) Say about this?
Ranked passages from the local William Branham sermon and Church Age Book database. Relevance is relative, not a statement of doctrinal certainty.
The Ministry explained
56-1001 §48
And now, when he's down, he's just a bird, but when he's... He was sitting with David. He said, "David, do all that's in your heart for God is with you." I love that. And that night the Lord appeared to His prophet and said, "Go tell My servant, David, 'You was a little fellow and I took you from the sheepcote, from feeding your father's flock, to give you a great name among men. And I've been with you, and I have caused those who's contraried you and so forth, but I can't let you build this temple. But ever since...
The unwelcomed Christ
55-1002 §35
That was part of the treasures that the Queen of Sheba brought to Solomon, very expensive, spikenard. So, they'd anoint the face and so forth. Now, he had his feet washed, and dried, and his slippers put on. And all the stink of the road was off of him. And now, the rays of the sun... He'd rub his face real good, and took a towel and wiped the oil from it. Now, the next courtesy the host showed: When he walked in to the door, as he went in, why the host would be standing there when his visitor came, and when he cam...
The great warrior David
55-0118 §54
So he walks up, and he went walking up with ... here went Philip and Nathanael walking along. Jesus standing like this, and they'd walked up into the audience. After awhile Jesus looked around over the audience, He seen Philip standing over there and seen Nathanael standing there with a lot of curiosity, you know, He thought... You know, they'd maybe seen Him heal somebody or something, he said, "You know I kind of believe that." Maybe some woman come up and He said, "Now lady, you're possessed with certain, certai...
The Queen of Sheba
60-0710 §95
Our blessed heavenly Father, they came from the east and west, north and south to hear the wisdom, spirit of discernment that was on Your servant, Solomon. And when Your Son, the Lord Jesus, was here on earth, He told them, that how they had condemned in their generation the thing that Solomon's generation had cherished. And how that they had prospered in Solomon's generation, and how they would be polluted in His generation; and yet He was greater than Solomon. And today, Father, it's a greater day than it was the...
Then Jesus came and called
64-0213 §25
David, sitting as a rejected king up on the hill, weeping because he was rejected... Eight hundred years after that, the Son of David sat on a hill. That was the Spirit of Christ in David there. And He ... why, He was both root and offspring of David. And so He sat upon the hill, weeping as a rejected king. "Jerusalem, Jerusalem, how often would I have hovered you as a hen her brood." What was it? It was Christ, back there. It was Christ crying, when David wrote the hymn, "My God, why has thou forsaken me? All my b...